Selecting a letting agent is one of the most important decisions a landlord can make. A good agency can protect your investment, ensure reliable tenants, and save you countless hours of stress. A poor choice, however, can cost you money, time, and even damage your property’s reputation.
Here’s a short story that illustrates the importance of asking the right questions — followed by a practical checklist you can use before signing up with any property management company.
Mr. Smith owned his first rental property and wanted help managing it. He quickly chose the cheapest agency he could find, without much research. Unfortunately:
The agency didn’t properly reference tenants.
Rent payments were late, with no follow-up.
Maintenance issues were ignored until they became expensive repairs.
Within a year, Mr. Smith regretted his decision.
Meanwhile, Mrs. Jones also owned her first rental property. She took her time, asked the right questions, and checked credentials. Her chosen agent:
Provided thorough tenant vetting.
Issued clear monthly statements.
Responded quickly to maintenance.
Was regulated by industry bodies like ARLA Propertymark and The Property Ombudsman.
Mrs. Jones enjoyed peace of mind and a steady return on her investment.
The difference? Careful selection.
Are you regulated by a professional body?
Look for ARLA Propertymark, RICS, NAEA, or The Property Ombudsman. Regulation means accountability.
How do you reference tenants?
A strong vetting process is vital — credit checks, employment references, previous landlord references, and affordability assessments.
How do you handle rent collection and arrears?
Ask how rent is collected, when it’s paid to you, and what happens if a tenant falls behind.
What is your maintenance procedure?
Check whether they have approved contractors, emergency cover, and transparent cost controls.
How do you communicate with landlords?
Ask how often you’ll receive updates, whether you get monthly statements, and if there’s a landlord portal.
What are your fees — and what’s included?
Low fees can hide poor service. Make sure you understand exactly what you’re paying for and what costs extra.
Do you carry client money protection and professional indemnity insurance?
This ensures your money and your property are financially safeguarded.
Reviews and testimonials online.
How long they’ve been established in the area.
Their track record with similar properties to yours.
Sample tenancy agreements, management contracts, and landlord reports.
At 247 Property Services, we believe in complete transparency. We’ve managed over 1,000 homes in Doncaster since 2003, with a reputation for matching great tenants with great homes. Our landlords trust us because we:
Deliver thorough vetting services.
Provide clear statements and communication.
Respond quickly to tenants and landlords alike.
Operate under strict professional regulation.
Choosing the right letting agency isn’t just about price — it’s about trust, professionalism, and peace of mind.
Back to Blog